The dream of a second CAF Champions League crown slipped through Mamelodi Sundowns’ fingers once again, following a 3–2 aggregate defeat to Egypt’s Pyramids FC in the 2025 final. Despite entering the contest as favorites and showcasing domestic dominance throughout the season, Sundowns were undone by tactical frailty, key omissions, and a spirited Pyramids side that claimed their first-ever continental title.
The decisive blow came in Cairo’s June 30 Stadium, where Pyramids edged the second leg 2–1 after holding Sundowns to a 1–1 draw in Pretoria. It was a historic night for the Egyptian outfit, but for Sundowns, the result has raised tough questions about their continental pedigree and strategic direction.
The Zwane Conundrum
At the heart of the post-match inquest is the absence of captain Themba Zwane. Having returned from an Achilles injury well before the final, many expected the midfield maestro to feature at some point over the two legs. But coach Miguel Cardoso opted to keep him sidelined, citing fitness concerns. The decision has sparked widespread debate, with pundits and fans alike arguing that Sundowns lacked the creativity and leadership Zwane typically brings to high-stakes games.
Zwane's experience could have proved vital against a compact and disciplined Pyramids defense. Without him, Sundowns appeared to lack inspiration in the final third, often recycling possession without threatening their opponents meaningfully.
Tactical Shortcomings
Statistically, Sundowns held the upper hand. In the second leg, they dominated possession with 64% and matched Pyramids in attempts on goal. Yet their control of the ball did not translate into control of the match. Pyramids were more clinical, more urgent, and more coherent in their approach, especially when they surged ahead in the second half.
The South African champions only shifted into a higher gear after falling behind, but by then, it was too late. This recurring issue of delayed urgency and reactive strategy has haunted Sundowns in past continental campaigns — and once again proved costly.
Pressure Mounts on Coach Cardoso
For coach Miguel Cardoso, the loss compounds growing pressure. Appointed in December 2024, the Portuguese tactician was entrusted with delivering a second star to Chloorkop. Instead, he has now suffered back-to-back CAF Champions League final defeats, having previously fallen short with Tunisia's Espérance.
Cardoso’s meticulous style has delivered consistency in the league, but his continental record is under intense scrutiny. Questions are now being asked about his big-match temperament, squad selections, and inability to adapt tactically when it matters most.
A Glimpse of Redemption?
All is not lost for Sundowns. The team has already secured a place in the upcoming expanded FIFA Club World Cup in the United States, where they will face global heavyweights such as Borussia Dortmund and Fluminense. Domestically, they remain in the hunt for a historic treble, with the Betway Premiership and Nedbank Cup still within reach.
However, continental failure continues to be the blemish on an otherwise dominant era for the Tshwane giants. As the dust settles, Sundowns must confront their shortcomings head-on — reassessing squad depth, tactical identity, and mental preparedness — if they are to truly become a powerhouse on the African stage once more.
Post a Comment